James F. Butler Jr. convicted of raping child in Kenner

A Jefferson Parish jury on Thursday evening (Oct. 22) found James F. Butler Jr. guilty of sexually abusing a child at least three times while living in Kenner, beginning when the child was 7 or 8 years old. 

Butler, 33, of Houston, Texas, was convicted as charged of first-degree rape of a victim under 13, sexual battery of a juvenile under age 13 and indecent behavior with a juvenile under age 13. 

When arrested in 2024, Butler denied abusing the child and asserted he had little memory of the timeframe during which the abuse occurred when he lived in Kenner, due to his seizure disorder. 

“The defendant claims he can’t remember,” Assistant District Attorney Sarah Helmstetter told jurors in closing argument Thursday. “But you know who does remember? The victim.”  

The child was 12 years old when the the child’s parents located a text message on the victim’s phone from a friend that caused them concern. When the parents confronted the victim with the text message, the victim disclosed what Butler had done years earlier when he was living with the family in Kenner. The parents later notified the Kenner Police Department. 

The child said the first incident occurred when Butler was watching the victim and siblings while their parents were out on a date night. The siblings were in another room in the home when Butler summonsed the child to the living room under the pretense of getting a math book. He sexually abused the child. 

On at least two subsequent occasions, Butler sexually abused the child, including in his car. In one of those incidents, Butler entered the child’s bedroom, locked the door and said, “please, it’s the last time.” The child’s father went to the bedroom and asked why the door was locked. Butler said it closed by accident. Butler again abused the child later that evening. 

Butler moved to Texas in early 2021. When he returned to Kenner for a visit in November 2021, the child ran away from home. The child’s parents notified Kenner police before the child returned home. Without explanation, Butler returned to Texas the same day. 

Following the disclosure to Kenner police, the child recounted the abuse to a forensic interviewer at the Jefferson Children’s Advocacy Center. Of the first incident, the child relayed to the forensic interviewer that Butler said, “let’s finish what we were doing,” as he escalated the abuse from a kiss to a sexual act. 

Kenner police obtained a warrant for Butler’s arrest. U.S Marshals arrested him on the Jefferson Parsh warrant in Houston in July 2024. 

Jurors deliberated just over an hour in finding Butler guilty. Judge R. Christopher Cox of the 24th Judicial District Court is scheduled to sentence Butler on Nov. 10. The mandatory punishment for first-degree rape of a juvenile under age 13 is life in prison without benefit of probation, parole or suspension of sentence. 

Assistant District Attorneys Sarah Helmstetter and Theresa King prosecuted the case.