A Jefferson Parish jury on Thursday (Dec. 5) found Anthony Morgan guilty of brazenly ambushing a man who was sitting in his car at an Airline Drive intersection in Metairie when he was fatally shot.
Morgan, 44, of Metairie, was convicted of the second-degree murder of Aaron Lee, 44, also of Metairie. Lee was shot multiple times as he sat in the driver’s seat of his Dodge Charger, waiting for the traffic light to change at Airline Drive and Turnbull Drive on April 25, 2022.
Responding to 911 calls at about 12:45 a.m., Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office deputies found Lee inside the Charger, which was in westbound Airline’s left turn lane. Although he was shot four times, including a fatal wound to his left eye, Lee had not yet died. He had a loaded shotgun with a sawed-off barrel in his lap.
Nearby, the deputies found an unoccupied Infiniti M37, in Turnbull’s northbound lane at Airline – the car Morgan was in.
Detectives obtained surveillance footage from nearby businesses showing Morgan arriving at the intersection in the Infiniti. Seventeen seconds later, he stepped out of the vehicle, stumbling at first and losing his cap.
Carrying an assault-style semiautomatic rifle, Morgan began shooting as he backed away from Lee. Morgan then changed course, aggressively moving toward Lee, in all firing more than 47 .223-caliber bullets as he focused his fire on his target.
“That’s a guerilla-style ambush in the middle of Airline Highway,” Assistant District Attorney Brendan Bowen told jurors in closing argument Thursday.
Morgan, who lived a half-block from the murder scene, then fled on foot into the adjacent neighborhood, leaving the Infiniti and his cap on the roadway.
Detectives found a car registered to Morgan parked nearby with the rifle he used inside it, along with his cell phone. The detectives identified Morgan as the shooter and obtained an arrest warrant. A U.S. Marshals Service fugitive task force arrested Morgan four days after the shooting at an apartment in eastern New Orleans.
Detectives also learned that Lee and Morgan had been intimately involved with the same woman, and that there were ongoing hostilities between the men.
Morgan initially denied involvement and told a detective that he was with “a call girl” when Lee was shot. However, his DNA was recovered from the cap that fell from his head as he stumbled out of the Infiniti. Morgan now asserts self-defense.
Morgan told jurors Wednesday he carried an assault-style rifle for protection and said he had heard that Lee believed he killed an acquaintance in the Shrewsbury neighborhood. He described himself as the victim of an ambush and started shooting Lee only after Lee stepped out of his car and pointed a rifle at him as a second gunman fired from behind him.
However, evidence shows that Lee was seated inside his car when he was shot in his left eye, and that the bullet had passed through the windshield or driver’s side window and was tumbling when it struck him, according to the pathologist who conducted the autopsy and a crime scene reconstruction expert. Further, there was no blood or biological matter found on the outside of Lee’s white car, indicating that he had not stepped out of the driver’s seat to shoot at Morgan when he was shot.
The evidence shows that Morgan was not in imminent danger when he shot Lee, meaning his actions in shooting Lee were not reasonable or justifiable, Assistant District Attorney Kristen Landrieu told jurors Thursday. “Aaron Lee should be with his family,” she argued. “He should be celebrating birthdays and Christmas and Thanksgiving. And he’s not, because Anthony Morgan took things into his own hands. This is a second-degree murder. There is no other option.”
Following his arrest and while held in the Jefferson Parish Correctional Center, Morgan enlisted Brittany M. Schoeppner and Joseph A. Freeman Jr., to retrieve a semiautomatic rifle from his apartment to hinder the ongoing murder investigation. They complied with the request.
Schoeppner, 32, of Kenner, pleaded guilty on July 11 to obstruction of justice and to being a convicted felon in possession of a firearm. She then pleaded guilty under the state’s habitual offender law and was sentenced to 13 years and four months in prison. She was forbidden to carry firearms because of prior a narcotic conviction in New Orleans.
Freeman, 58, of Metairie, pleaded guilty on April 11 to obstruction of justice and to being a convicted felon in possession of a firearm. He received a 10-year prison sentence. He was forbidden from possessing firearms because of a prior narcotics conviction in Jefferson Parish and a simple burglary conviction in New Orleans.
In addition to second-degree murder, Morgan was convicted of three counts of being a convicted felon in possession of a firearm and two counts of obstruction of justice. He was prohibited from carrying firearms because of narcotics convictions in New Orleans.
The jury that was seated Monday deliberated less than one hour in finding him guilty of all six counts.
Judge June Berry Darensburg of the 24th Judicial District Court is scheduled to sentence Morgan on Jan. 23.
Assistant District Attorneys Kristen Landrieu and Brendan Bowen prosecuted the case.