A Jefferson Parish judge on Wednesday (Dec. 4) sentenced Cody Labranche to back-to-back life sentences, plus 40 years in prison for his conviction of murdering two men in their Metairie home.
Labranche, 30, of Ponchatoula, received the mandatory sentence for the first-degree murders of Jonathan Pizzuto, 39, and his roommate William Mitchell, 36.
Labranche shot the men in the living room of their home in the 600 block of Rosa Avenue on Jan. 17, 2002, as the victims played video games. Pizzuto had been in a long-term romantic relationship with Labranche’s sister, who overdosed inside the residence in July 2020. Labranche blamed Pizzuto for her death.
Following his arrest and during his trial, Labranche asserted self-defense, saying that as he entered the living room, he thought Mitchell was reaching for a weapon. So, he opened fire. The crime scene reconstruction refutes Labranche’s self-defense claim.
A Jefferson Parish jury on Nov. 8 found Labranche guilty as charged.
Click here to read about the trial.
In addition to the murders, Labranche was convicted of obstruction of justice, for hindering the investigation by disposing of the murder weapon. He told detectives he tossed the pistol in a river.
On Wednesday, family members recounted in victim-impact testimony how Pizzuto deeply mourned Labranche’s sister’s death; they were a couple for more than a decade, and their ashes are together now “for eternity,” one relative said.
“You killed these boys because you were evil and sick-minded,” Pizzuto’s mother testified, adding that Pizzuto’s teenage nephew was playing video games with his uncle on that night and heard the gunfire through the tv game console, unaware of what was happening.
In a prepared statement read aloud in court, Mitchell’s sister said her brother “died trying to get out of the door” when Labranche began shooting. She noted her brother also mourned the death of Labranche’s sister and even drove from California to attend her funeral.
Judge Ellen Shirer Kovach of the 24th Judicial District Court sentenced Labranche to life in prison without benefit of probation, parole or suspension of sentence, and 40 years for the obstruction of justice. Judge Kovach ran the sentences consecutively.
Assistant District Attorneys Megan Gorman and Alyssa Aleman prosecuted the case.