GRETNA, La. – Jefferson Parish District Attorney Paul D. Connick Jr. announced today that his office will not seek criminal charges against JPSO narcotics Detectives Paul Carmouche and Mike Wibble. This matter arises out of a narcotics investigation conducted by the Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office that resulted in the deaths of Chris Joseph and Daviri Robertson.

“The role of the District Attorney in all criminal cases is to seek justice,” D.A. Connick said. “This is done by pursuing the evidence and law according to the highest standards of ethics and integrity, and by determining the facts from an independent, objective and neutral perspective.

“While a homicide is the killing of one person by another, not every homicide is a crime,” D.A. Connick said. “As in all cases, our review must focus upon the elements of proof as well as any legal justifications or defenses that may apply.”

Upon receipt of the Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office’s report, in which homicide detectives concluded that lethal force was justified, this office began a comprehensive and independent review of this matter without regard to costs, resources or the time required to reach a fair and just decision. As part of our initial review, this office consulted with use-of-force expert, JPSO Lt. Benny Griffin.  Additionally, this office retained independent use-of-force expert Sheriff Ken Katsaris (retired) to provide an opinion on the detectives’ actions in this case.

Both experts agree that the application of deadly force in this situation was reasonable and comports with recognized, accepted and law enforcement training practices.

In light of the evidence reviewed in this matter, the State cannot prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the actions of the detectives rise to the level of criminal conduct.

The D.A.’s Office has published on its website, www.jpda.us, its final report on the matter, outlining the details of its review, analysis of this case and reasons for the decision. Click here to read the District Attorney’s report.