Month: July 2023

On parole for ’94 homicide, Shawn Carter convicted of robbing Gretna store using a hammer

A Jefferson Parish jury on Wednesday (July 26) found Shawn Carter guilty of robbing a Gretna convenience store while using a hammer.

Carter, 50, of Avondale, is guilty as charged of the armed robbery of the business. At the time he committed this crime, Carter was on parole for killing a man by beating him to death with a hammer.

About 12:30 a.m., on Feb. 11, 2021, Carter walked into the convenience store in the 900 block of Lafayette Street. He immediately approached the 42-year-old clerk who was seated behind the counter.

Wielding the hammer, Carter demanded the clerk hand over his phone and to refrain from activating a panic alarm. He ordered the clerk to open the cash register and threatened to kill the clerk if he didn’t comply.

In opening the register, the clerk dropped the cash drawer. Carter ordered the clerk to pick up the money. The clerk refused, and so Carter grabbed him by the throat and pushed him to the floor.

Carter pocketed the money, and the clerk fled to a stock room and locked the door. Through a window in the door, the clerk observed Carter taking three bottles of liquor and fleeing on Lafayette Street toward the Mississippi River.

In addition to the cash and liquor, Carter stole the clerk’s iPhone. An hour later, Gretna Police Department detectives tracked the stolen phone to a yard in the 600 block of 6th Street, about six blocks away from the crime scene. Carter’s fingerprint later was found on the phone, leading detectives to identify Carter as their suspect.

As he fled into the residential neighborhood after committing the armed robbery, Carter discarded his Atlanta Falcons cap and shirt in the 400 block of 9th Street. Gretna police recovered that evidence using a canine, Max, which tracked Carter’s scent from the crime scene. While canvassing the area for more evidence, officers found the claw hammer in a storm drain in that same block.

The U.S. Marshals Fugitive Task Force located and arrested Carter at his Avondale home on March 3, 2021.

A Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office Crime Lab DNA analyst, meanwhile, found Carter’s genetic material on the cap, shirt and hammer.

On June 1, 1994, Carter used a hammer to beat Christian Smith to death. Smith, 20, was found in his home in the 2100 block of Hancock Street in Gretna. The hammer was still embedded in his skull.

Carter fled with the Smith’s car and his property, including a mobile phone. Indicted for first-degree murder, he pleaded guilty in 1996 to manslaughter and was sentenced to 40 years in prison. He was paroled in 2014.

The jury, which heard evidence about the 1994 homicide, deliberated less than 50 minutes in finding Carter guilty as charged of the armed robbery. Judge Ray Steib of the 24th Judicial District Court is scheduled to sentence Carter on Aug. 21.

Assistant District Attorneys Laura Schneidau and Blaine Moncrief prosecuted the case.

Lamonte Loggins convicted of murdering Kenner store clerk during armed robbery

A Jefferson Parish jury on Wednesday evening (July 26) convicted Lamonte Loggins of standing over a helpless convenience store clerk during an armed robbery in Kenner and firing a 9mm bullet into his chest, killing him.

Loggins, 30, of Kenner, is guilty as charged of the first-degree murder of Abd El Ghader Sylla, 30. Sylla, whose wife was pregnant with their child, was working the overnight shift at the business at Williams Boulevard and West Esplanade Avenue when Loggins shot him.

Mortally wounded, Sylla still was able to call 911, saying he was “about to die.”

“I got shot. I got robbed, and I got shot,” he told the 911 operator before dropping the phone. He died from his injury soon after at a New Orleans hospital.

Loggins and his older brother, Eric Rodgers, planned the armed robbery and cased the business hours earlier. About 2 a.m., on Nov. 30, 2020, Rodgers entered the store, followed by Loggins. Because of the COVID-19 pandemic, they wore masks.

After pouring a cup of coffee and discussing liquor with Sylla, Loggins brandished a 9mm pistol and demanded cash. As he pulled out the pistol, a latex glove fell out of his pocket – Loggins’ DNA later was found on that glove.

Sylla dropped to his knees and held his hands over his head as he complied with Loggins’ demands. Sylla opened the register and removed the cash drawer so Loggins could get the money.

Without being provoked, Loggins then walked around the counter and began beating Sylla in the head with the pistol. Sylla fell onto his back as the beating continued. Loggins stood back and fired the bullet into Sylla’s chest, even as the victim pleadingly held his hands in the air in front of him.

Loggins and Rodgers fled to their car parked blocks away, as Sylla, still on his back on the floor behind the counter, called 911. He remained there until Kenner Police Department officers arrived.

During the ensuing investigation, Kenner Police Department detectives used numerous businesses’ and residences’ video surveillance cameras to track the suspects’ movement from the crime scene to the Lorie Drive apartment complex where both men lived.

But Loggins and Rodgers had gone to Biloxi, Miss., where they spent a night in a hotel and where Loggins threw the pistol into a business’s garbage receptacle. The following day, they caught bus to Memphis, Tenn., where they previously lived.

More than a week later, Rodgers called the Kenner Police Department. He told the lead case detective, Aaron Savoie, that Loggins killed Sylla. Federal marshals and local police arrested Loggins in Memphis on Dec. 8, 2020.

Rodgers, 32, pleaded guilty on Sept. 28, 2022 to manslaughter, obstruction of justice and armed robbery for his role in the crime. He received a 40-year sentence.

On Tuesday, as part of a plea agreement, Rodgers testified that he and Loggins planned the robbery, and that he was a participant because his government unemployment assistance hadn’t been credited to his debit card. But Rodgers testified that he did not know Loggins was going to shoot the clerk.

Under cross-examination by Loggins’ public defender, Rodgers was accused of urging Loggins to shoot Sylla. Rodgers, who has distinctive tattoos on his forehead and hands, was a regular customer at the business and could be easily identified, Loggins’ attorney argued. The defense attorney also argued that the state did not prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the gunshot killed Sylla, suggesting that  the medical treatment the victim received at the hospital could have caused his death.

The jury deliberated about an hour before returning with its verdicts. In addition to first-degree murder, jurors found Loggins guilty as charged of obstruction of justice, for tossing the murder weapon in a business’s garbage receptacle in Biloxi. Loggins also tossed the bullets from that pistol in a drainage canal in Kenner before he and Rodgers fled the state.

Judge Ellen Shirer Kovach of the 24th Judicial District Court is scheduled to sentence Loggins Aug. 9.

Assistant District Attorneys Carolyn Chkautovich and Brittany Beckner prosecuted the case.

 

Convicted of murdering Harvey teen, Ivory Franklin sentenced to life again in ‘Ramos’ retrial

A Jefferson Parish judge on Tuesday (July 18) sentenced Ivory Franklin to life in prison plus 40 years for his convictions of murder and attempted murder.

It brings to two the number of times that Franklin, 25, has been convicted and sentenced for killing Reginald Black, 17, in Harvey seven years ago, and trying to kill Black’s 15-year-old nephew. The trio, who were close friends, were walking to a convenience store about 3 a.m., when Franklin brandished a pistol and shot Black in the back of his head.

In 2018, a non-unanimous Jefferson Parish jury convicted Franklin as charged of second-degree murder and attempted second-degree murder for the crimes. However, because of the jury’s non-unanimity, Franklin received a new trial after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in its 2020 decision, Ramos v. Louisiana, that non-unanimous verdicts are unconstitutional.

Franklin was convicted again in March, this time by a unanimous jury. And for a second time, 24th Judicial District Judge Donnie Rowan sentenced Franklin to mandatory life in prison for the second-degree murder of Black, and to 40 years in prison for the attempted second-degree murder of the 15-year-old.

“I don’t know why an individual would kill someone who was like a brother to them,” Judge Rowan told Franklin in handing down the consecutive sentences.

Franklin was 18 years old in May 2016, when he shot Black in the back of his head as they walked along the drainage canal bank in Harvey’s Woodmere subdivision. The 15-year-old ran for his life while Franklin shot at him, too. That teenager was able to alert a nearby homeowner, who called the Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office.

Assistant District Attorneys Douglas Rushton and Stephen Downer prosecuted Franklin.

‘Street Butler,’ who led violent West Bank-based narcotics ring, pleads guilty

A Jefferson Parish judge has sentenced Scott Butler to 20 years in prison for his role as the leader of a Jefferson Parish narcotics distribution ring. Butler’s guilty plea on July 13 brings to a close a racketeering case that involved 11 codefendants who engaged in importing pain pills and muscle relaxers from overseas for resale on the streets of the greater New Orleans area.

Butler, 36, of Marrero, known as “Street Butler,” was the central figure in the enterprise, importing thousands of Tramadol and Soma pills from India or Singapore into the area for resale on local streets and distributing the proceeds among the enterprise’s members between November 2015 and April 2021.

Members of the enterprise used threats of violence to protect their distribution ring from those who encroached in their territory or reported them to authorities. Members of the enterprise attempted to kill an Algiers man in 2015. When that failed, they then tried to buy his silence with a bribe. When that failed, they attempted to kill him again. The man and his girlfriend were murdered the following year.

Court documents show Scott Butler wired almost $165,000 in a series of about 85 transactions to sources in India to purchase the pills. As a result of the investigation, the Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office seized over 80,000 pills, seven firearms and almost $30,000 cash.

All other members of the enterprise also pleaded guilty during the past two years:

  • Christopher Butler, 34, of Marrero, was another supervising member and an enforcer who committed and threatened use of violence to protect the enterprise. He pleaded guilty to racketeering, conspiracy to distribute narcotics, possession with intent to distribute narcotics and public bribery counts on May 1. He received a 20-year prison sentence, with 10 years of that sentence being suspended.
  • Decorian Jefferson, 31, of Marrero, was a “mid-level” dealer who distributed the pills throughout the greater New Orleans area. Jefferson pleaded guilty on Aug. 4, 2021, to racketeering, conspiracy to distribute narcotics, conspiracy to launder money of amounts greater than $100,000 and possession with intent to distribute narcotics. He received a 17-year prison sentence.
  • Dwayne Carter, 30, of Gretna, was a “mid-level” distributor who distributed the pills throughout the greater New Orleans area. He pleaded guilty on Sept. 29, 2021, to racketeering, conspiracy to distribute narcotics, conspiracy to launder money in amounts greater than $100,000 and public bribery. He received a 10-year sentence.
  • April Butler, 41, of Marrero, was a “mid-level facilitator” who provided the site for the imported pills. She pleaded guilty on June 9, 2021 to racketeering, conspiracy to distribute narcotics, conspiracy to launder money of amounts greater than $100,000 and possession with intent to distribute narcotics. She received a suspended 20-year sentence and was ordered to serve three years of active probation.
  • Shirley Carter Butler, 60, of Terrytown, was a “mid-level facilitator” who provided a site for the pills. She pleaded guilty on May 26, 2021 to racketeering, conspiracy to distribute narcotics, conspiracy to launder money in amounts greater than $100,000 and possession with intent to distribute narcotics. She received a suspended 10-year prison sentence and was ordered to serve three years of active probation. She is the mother of Scott Butler, Christopher Butler and April Butler.
  • Jemimah Joseph, 36, of Marrero, was a “mid-level facilitator” who provided storage for the pills. She pleaded guilty on Oct. 11 to racketeering, conspiracy to distribute narcotics, conspiracy to launder money in amounts greater than $100,000 and possession with intent to distribute narcotics. She received a 10-year prison sentence that was suspended and was ordered to serve three years of active probation.
  • Devin Williams, 25, of Gretna, was a “street-level distributor” who sold the pills throughout the greater New Orleans area. He pleaded guilty on Feb. 15 to racketeering, conspiracy to distribute narcotics, conspiracy to launder money in amounts greater than $100,000 and possession with intent to distribute narcotics. He received a suspended 8-year prison sentence and was ordered to serve three years of active probation.
  • Terrell Carter, 25, of Melissa, Texas, was a “street-level distributor” in the enterprise. He pleaded guilty on Oct. 11 to racketeering, conspiracy to distribute narcotics, conspiracy to launder money in amounts greater than $100,000 and possession with intent to distribute narcotics. He received a suspended 5-year sentence and was ordered to serve three years or active probation.
  • Trenise Palmer, 38, of Westwego, was a “street-level facilitator” who provided a site for the importation of pills. She pleaded guilty on Aug. 19, 2021, to racketeering, conspiracy to distribute narcotics, conspiracy to launder money in amounts greater than $100,000 and possession with intent to distribute narcotics. She received three years of active probation.
  • Lauren Jackson, 37, of Westwego, was a “street-level facilitator” who provided a site for the importation of pills. She pleaded guilty on May 27, 2021 to racketeering, conspiracy to distribute narcotics and conspiracy to launder money in amounts greater than $100,000. She received three years of active probation.

Judge Michael Mentz of the 24th Judicial District Court presided over the cases.

Assistant District Attorneys Douglas Rushton, Brittany Beckner, Leo Aaron and former Assistant District Attorney Joshua Vanderhooft prosecuted the case.

 

Stephen Sauer pleads guilty to drugging, molesting 17 men, gets 25-year sentence

A Jefferson Parish judge on Friday (July 7) sentenced Stephen Sauer to 25 years in prison, after he pleaded guilty to being a serial sexual predator who drugged 17 men he met in the French Quarter and drove the unconscious victims to his Metairie home. There, he used mobile devices to obtain images of the victims in various stages of undress; he molested some of the men.

Sauer, 61, admitted to targeting men who appeared to be intoxicated, lost or in need of assistance. Then, in offering to help, he drugged the men. In some cases, he put narcotics in their drinks while at bars or, after they passed out from drinking alcohol, he used an eyedropper to feed them the sleep-inducing substances.

Sauer then drove the victims to his home in the 4700 block of Purdue Drive, where he photographed or videotaped the unconscious men. He molested some of the men and pleasured himself, and the following morning he gave them rides to their hotels or other locations.

He shared his images with others through a website or traded the images with others via email, the Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office found in its investigation.

Many of the victims were visiting New Orleans from out of state, were separated from friends or simply lost when Sauer approached them and offered help. The crimes for which he was charged occurred over a two-year period beginning in 2019.

Sauer pleaded guilty to 13 counts of sexual battery, nine counts of third-degree rape, 17 counts of video voyeurism and to 16 misdemeanor charges of possessing legend drugs without prescriptions and possession of drug paraphernalia.

Sauer admitted his crimes and pled guilty as charged in 24th Judicial District Judge Shayna Beevers Morvant’s court and was sentenced to a total of 25 years in prison. The judge additionally ordered Sauer to register as a sex offender for the rest of his life, and to refrain from contacting 12 of his victims for the rest of his life.

The investigation began in June 2021, after Sauer sent a computer hard drive to an electronics repair company in New York. A data recovery technician found hundreds of images suggesting sexual assaults had taken place. New York law enforcement officials determined the images were taken in Metairie and notified the Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office.

Detectives were able to identify many victims in part because Sauer took photographs of their driver’s licenses or other forms of identification.

In Sauer’s home, detectives found prescription pill bottles in the name of a convicted sex offender in Missouri. The narcotics included a common “date rape” drug, Zolpidem.

Detectives believe that more than 50 victims remain unidentified.

Assistant District Attorneys Kellie Rish and Rachel Africk prosecuted the case.

 

 

 

Shawn Chiasson pleads guilty as charged to murdering ex-girlfriend

A Jefferson Parish judge on Wednesday (July 5) sentenced Shawn Chiasson to spend the rest of his life in prison after the defendant abruptly ended his murder trial and pleaded guilty as charged to killing his estranged girlfriend.

Chiasson, 28, of Marrero, pleaded guilty to the second-degree murder of Lindsey Williams, 29, by shooting her once in the left side of her head in the bedroom of her home in the 1100 block of Gaudet Drive. He then fled, leaving her 11-year-old son behind with his dying mother on the morning of Aug. 14, 2021.

The jury that was seated last week returned to 24th Judicial District Judge Ray Steib’s courtroom on Wednesday to hear testimony. Jurors heard the state’s opening statement. Jurors heard testimony from Williams’ mother and were midway through the direct examination of Chiasson’s ex-girlfriend when he decided to plead guilty.

In addition to second-degree murder, Chiasson pleaded guilty as charged to being a convicted felon in possession of a firearm and to obstruction of justice. He was prohibited from possessing firearms because of a 2021 conviction of possession of heroin. After he shot Williams, Chiasson fled to Westwego, where he dumped the pistol along a canal bank – leading to the obstruction of justice charge.

Judge Steib sentenced Chiasson to the mandatory life sentence for the murder, 20 years for the firearm charge and 40 for the obstruction of justice. He ran the sentences concurrently.

On the night before her death, Williams gathered with friends at a downtown Gretna restaurant and then on the Mississippi River levee. Chiasson arrived and texted her, “I’m looking dead at you.”

Just before 9 a.m., the following morning, her son was in his bedroom when he heard something across the hall in his mother’s bedroom. He opened the door and saw Chiasson with blood on his hands.

Chiasson then used the child’s cell phone to call 911, telling the operator that his name was “Jake,” and saying someone had been shot. Chiasson fled, and the child waited on the front porch for the Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office to arrive.

Following his arrest two days later, Chiasson told detectives that the pistol accidentally fired as he removed it from his pants’ waistband.

Chiasson’s public defender waived giving an opening statement Wednesday. Chiasson’s ex-girlfriend was the second witness, who was called to testify about a 2017 incident in which he beat her while she was eight months pregnant. She refused to answer a prosecutor’s questions Wednesday and faced a contempt hearing. It was while she was on the witness stand that Chiasson told his public defender that he would plead guilty as charged.

Jurors briefly left the courtroom on Wednesday, unaware that Chiasson was pleading guilty. Judge Steib called the jurors back to his courtroom and told him about the guilty plea. The jurors voluntarily remained in court to hear victim impact testimony and to see Chiasson sentenced.

Assistant District Attorneys Lindsay Truhe and Tommy Block prosecuted the case.